Document Type : Original articles
Authors
1 B.Sc. Nursing, Faculty of Nursing, Minia University
2 Professor of Community Health Nursing, Minia University
3 Assistant Professor of Community Health, Faculty of Nursing, Minia University
Abstract
Keywords
Stroke is a medical emergency, the gap between recovery and impairment or death for people who had a stroke is measured in hours, it is critical for healthcare practitioners to have a basic awareness of stroke and how to respond to it as part of their daily routine (Taylor et al., 2019). Stroke is the major cause of adult disability and the second largest cause of death, it can cause tingling and spasms in the muscles, as well as a lack of ability to detect heat and cold in the body, mind, and emotions. Weakness or paralysis of the extremities, swelling of the arms or legs, and tight or painful joints are all possible side effects (Goudie, 2017).
A stroke can leave a person with a feeling of fatigue that makes daily work difficult. A stroke can have a serious impact on how the brain processes information, depending on where the damage occurred. Memory, learning ability, and general awareness of the environment can be compromised; it can also impair your ability to communicate through speech and writing. The ability to read and concentrate can also be compromised. Sleep disorders can lead to poor memory and cognition (Armstrong, 2018).
Pay interest to the symptoms and signs begin, the duration of time they were gift can have an effect on your remedy options: trouble with speaking and understanding, paralysis or numbness of the face, arm or leg, trouble with seeing in a single or each eyes, sudden, excessive headache, which can be observed through vomiting, dizziness or altered attention and trouble with walking (Murano et al., 2019).
Healthy lifestyle which includes not smoking, maintaining a healthy weight, following a healthy diet, and daily exercise can reduce the risk of having a stroke to the half. The Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH) diet is high in fruits and vegetables, moderate in low-fat dairy products, and low in animal protein and can lower the risk of stroke. Stroke risk screenings are an ideal opportunity to lower stroke risk by identifying people or groups of people who are at high risk for stroke. Patients and the community must be educated about recognition and prevention of stroke. Research findings suggest that low-dose aspirin may lower the risk of stroke in women who are at risk (Boehme et al., 2017).
Caregiver is someone who accountable for getting to the wishes of a baby or based adult. A caregiver can offer a huge variety of service, relying at the diploma of disability, economic situation and living environment of the person disability (Reynolds et al., 2019).
The responsibilities of informal caregivers are as follows: Personal care such as (hygiene, nutrition, home care such as cleaning and meal preparation), auxiliary care such as (shopping and transportation), care such as (counseling and emotional support, conversation), and (Care plans such as (establishing and coordinating support for patients) (Brugiavini et al., 2019).
The main goal of teaching community care is to help stroke victims and caregivers achieve independence. The quality of education enhances the ability of clients and families to better care for their needs. Better results can be obtained by considering the client's learning needs in the context of the client's family and community. These results include improved care, ease of recovery, reduced complications of the disease and return to activities of daily living (ADLS) (Orchard et al., 2017)
The Community health nurse in home health care (HHC) is the roles of clinician that provide direct care to the clients and families, which include educator, investigator, administrator and consultant are seen in home health care. The experienced home health nurse manager or the administrator can fulfill this role (Mixon et al., 2020).
The aim of this study was to assess the care provided by family caregivers for post stroke patient at home
Globally, 70% of strokes and 87% of both stroke-related deaths and disability-adjusted life years occur in low- and middle-income countries. One in six people worldwide will have a stroke in their lifetime. Fifteen million people worldwide suffer a stroke each year and 5.8 million people die from its (Ramachandran & Rogers-R., 2019).Nearly seventy million people worldwide are affected with stroke annually with a mortality rate among them up to sex million and another sex million had left with permanent disability.
In Egypt, there are 14.8% of people are suffering from stroke, and 1600 cases died every year from stroke. About 47% of patient had at least two or more modifiable risk factors smoking, physical inactivity and hypertension (Aziz et al., 2019).
Post-stroke dementia was detected in 20.8% of patient, it was recorded more in old ages, illiterates, unmarried, unemployed, and those with recurrent stroke and with cerebral infarction. Post-stroke dementia is high in Egypt, especially in those with illiteracy, brain atrophy, severe strokes, and those presented with hemiplegia, sphincter affection, abnormal gait, and psychotic features (Al Fawal et al., 2021).
SUBJECT and METHODS
Aim of the Study
The aim of the current study was to assess the care provided by family caregivers for post stroke patient at home
- What is the care provided by family caregivers for post stroke patient at home
- Is there relationship between the care provided by family caregivers for post stroke patient at home and their socio-demographic characteristics?
A descriptive research design was utilized in this study.
This study was conducted at Minia University Hospital Neurology Outpatient Department. The hospital is located on the west bank of the Nile, opposite the Nile Upper Bridge, south of Minia city. The areas offered were on the western side of the city of Minia and the province of Minia. The hospital consists of two parts, the education part consists of classes for the education and training of medical and nursing students, and the second part consists of 37 outpatient departments and 27 inpatient departments in various specialties. Investigators choose this hospital because it has more cases than any other hospital. The outpatient clinic for nervous system patients in a university hospital works every Saturday and Wednesday and has three doctors (one senior and two juniors) and four nurses every day. Most cases of different age groups, most strokes, occur in the elderly and follow postoperative cases after neurosurgery. Servants of neurological clinic are serving neurological and stroke cases, providing appropriate treatment, wound care for postoperative cases, and referring cases to physiotherapy for rehabilitation
Purposive sampling of 180 patients who matched the research criteria was selected at outpatient stroke clinics. The sample was collected through six months from (from first July to the end December 2020). The investigator used to attend of the medical clinic in the Neurology department to follow up the cases, the average number of cases present daily in the clinic is approximately 150 cases that come to follow up. The clinic time was from 9 AM in the morning until 2 PM
Tools were adapted by investigator and it was a structured interviewing assessment questionnaire which is consisted of two tools:
The medical health history of post-stroke patients, it covers the medical diagnosis, date of occurrence, number of recurrence, and types of medications and present complaints (Cornelia et al., 2018).
2nd tool: consists of two parts :
Scoring system
The content validity of the data collection tools as a post stroke patient personal data questionnaire, the Barthel Index (activity of daily living) tool questionnaire and a post stroke care checklist. tools were submitted to five experts in community health nursing to test their validity. The tools were examined for content coverage, sequence of items, clarity, relevance, applicability, wording, length, format, and overall appearance. Based on experts` comments and recommendations; minor modifications had been made such as rephrasing and rearrangements of some sentences.
Internal consistency of interview questionnaire was assessed with the Cronbach's alpha coefficient. Cronbach's alpha coefficient of 0.00 indicates no reliability and a coefficient of 1.00 indicates perfect reliability. However, a reliability coefficient of 0.70 is acceptable. The reliability testing was performed for each tool and the results were as represented in table (A).
Tool title |
Cronbach’s Alpha |
Post stroke complications check list tool |
0.785 |
The Barthel activity of daily living (ADL) Index tool |
0.833 |
Post stroke care checklist tool |
0.565 |
Pilot Study
A pilot study will be conducted on 10 % of the sample to test study data collection tools in terms of their clarity, applicability, and time required to fulfill it. According to the results, based on the result of pilot study, the necessary modification in the items was done and included in the study.
A written approval obtained from the ethics and research committee of the Faculty of Nursing, Mina University. Oral consent obtained from each participant after explaining the nature & objectives of the study to gain their cooperation. Each assessment sheet was coded and subjects' names were not appearing on the sheets for the purpose of anonymity and confidentiality. Subjects were free to withdraw from the study at any time.
Permission to conduct the study was obtained from the manager of Minia University Hospital after explaining the importance and purpose of the study and obtained all permissions to collect data. The data were collected through six months from the beginning of July to the ending of December 2020. All needed sheets of the tool were printed, and data were collected from the caregivers. The investigator was meeting the patients and their caregivers in the clinic of nervous system patients in a university hospital that works every Saturday and Wednesday and has three doctors.
After consulting the doctors, I choose the cases based on the criteria shown in the study, if patient is able to check the form by himself or his caregiver Purpose of the study was explained to the caregivers before starting the interview where each caregiver was interviewed individually. Each caregiver took around 45: 60 minute to fill the tool. The investigator read questions and waits until caregivers complete the questionnaire for illiterate caregivers, while caregivers who read and write took questionnaire and filled it by themselves.
Questionnaire took about 60 minute for illiterate caregivers and 45-50 for educated caregivers to complete the tool. The investigator filled (3-5) tools from caregivers daily. Data was collected regarding patients' demographic characteristics, clinical data, knowledge regarding stroke and life style modifications, and factors affecting compliance among patients suffering from recurrent stroke through stroke patients' structured interview questionnaire.Then the investigator determined relation between compliance with life style modifications among patients suffering from cerebrovascular stroke.
The data will be tabulated and analyzed by using “statistical package for the social science “(SPSS), descriptive statistics will be utilized as, Frequency, percentage, mean and standard deviation. Qualitative variables were compared using Chi-square test Pearson correlation. P-value less 0.05 was considered as statically significant
Table (1): Distribution of studied caregiver according to demographic characteristics at Minia University Hospital (2020) (N=180).
Demographic characteristics |
No. |
% |
|
Age/ years |
40-45 |
31 |
17.2 |
45-50 |
50 |
27.8 |
|
50-55 |
49 |
27.2 |
|
55-60 |
50 |
27.8 |
|
Mean ± SD = 51.7 ± 6.7 year |
|||
Gender |
Male |
105 |
.3 |
Female |
75 |
41.7 |
|
Social status |
Single |
5 |
2.8 |
Married |
143 |
79.4 |
|
Divorced |
23 |
12.8 |
|
Widowed |
9 |
5.0 |
|
Education level |
Illiterate |
95 |
52.8 |
Reading and writing |
73 |
40.6 |
|
University education |
12 |
6.7 |
|
Income of family |
Sufficient |
60 |
33.3 |
Insufficient |
120 |
66.7 |
|
Type of family |
Extended |
170 |
94.4 |
Nuclear |
10 |
5.6 |
|
Number of family |
2-3 |
32 |
17.8 |
4-5 |
119 |
66.1 |
|
>5 |
29 |
16.1 |
Table (1) summarizes that, 53.2% of study sample their age ranges from 45:50 and 55:60 years old, with the Mean ± SD = 51.7 ± 6.7 year, 79% of them are married, 5% are widowed, 52.8 of them are illiterate, 6.7% has university education, 94% are extended families while 66.7% have insufficient income to their family and 66.1% of the client numbers of family is 4-5
Medical History |
No |
% |
|
Medical diagnosis |
Stroke |
87 |
48.3 |
Brain tumor |
15 |
8.3 |
|
Bleeding |
15 |
8.3 |
|
Hypertension |
63 |
35.0 |
|
Date of stroke |
Less than 6 months |
74 |
41.1 |
From 6 months to 1 year |
85 |
47.2 |
|
From one to two years |
16 |
8.9 |
|
More than two year |
5 |
2.8 |
|
Admitted in intensive care unit |
Yes |
58 |
32.8 |
No |
122 |
67.2 |
|
Duration of admission |
Less than 6 months |
24 |
13.3 |
From 6 months to 1 year |
17 |
9.4 |
|
From one to two years |
17 |
9.4 |
|
Total |
58 |
32.8 |
|
Not admitted |
122 |
67.2 |
|
Causes of admission |
Stroke |
11 |
6.1 |
Medical cause |
16 |
8.9 |
|
Surgical cause |
30 |
16.7 |
|
Tumor |
1 |
.6 |
|
Total |
58 |
32.2 |
|
Chronic diseases |
Hypertension |
88 |
48.9 |
Low blood pressure |
30 |
16.7 |
|
Heart disease |
36 |
20.0 |
|
Diabetes diseases |
12 |
6.7 |
|
Hyper cholistriod |
6 |
3.3 |
|
Anemia |
4 |
2.2 |
|
Not at all |
4 |
2.2 |
|
Smoking |
Cigarette smoker |
93 |
51.7 |
Hookah smoked |
39 |
21.7 |
|
Both together |
5 |
2.8 |
|
Non-smoker |
43 |
23.9 |
|
Neurologicaldisorder |
Brain clots |
40 |
22.2 |
Brain bleeding |
59 |
32.8 |
|
Fits |
21 |
11.7 |
|
Atherosclerosis |
11 |
6.1 |
|
Brain tumor |
49 |
27.2 |
Table (2) presents that, 48.9% of post-stroke patients are diagnosed as stroke and 35% is hypertension complication leaded to stroke happening as regard to onset of diagnosis occurrence stroke, 47.2% of them the date of stroke from 6month to 1 year, 32.8 % of them admitted to ICU unit. Only 32.8% admits by brain bleeding disorders. Regarding the presence of chronic diseases48.9% has hypertension and 20% has heart disease Also, 51.7% of them are cigarette smokers and 23.9 of them are non-smoker. Regarding the Neurological disorder 32.8% of them have brain bleeding and 22.2% of them have brain clots
|
No. |
% |
|
Post stroke Practice (Medications) Give patient Medications on time |
|
23 |
12.8 |
Did not performed |
54 |
30.0 |
|
Performed incompletely |
103 |
57.2 |
|
Use Medications in right way or methods |
Performed completely |
28 |
15.6 |
Did not performed |
70 |
38.9 |
|
Performed incompletely |
82 |
45.6 |
|
Use right dose and route |
Performed completely |
41 |
22.8 |
Did not performed |
66 |
36.7 |
|
Performed incompletely |
73 |
40.6 |
|
Regular diabetic and hypertensive drugs |
Performed completely |
47 |
26.1 |
Did not performed |
73 |
40.6 |
|
Performed incompletely |
60 |
33.3 |
|
Storage of medications |
Performed completely |
80 |
44.4 |
Did not performed |
49 |
27.2 |
|
Performed incompletely |
51 |
28.3 |
|
|
Performed completely |
|
|
Table (3) shows that, 57.2 %of caregivers give patient medications on time but only 12.8 %of them don’t. There are 45.6% of study clients use it in right way administration to deal with their patients on the other hand there is
15.6 % doesn’t. There are 40 % of study sample are on incomplete performance to diabetic and hypertensive drugs but 26 % of them are not completely, also 44.4% of them are not storing medications correctly
Items |
Care giver practice |
||
Barthel Index |
P value |
Pearson |
Sig. (2 ) |
|
1 |
0.022 |
0.773 |
NS = not significance P – value ≤ 0.05 *=significant
Table (4) shows that there is no significant correlation between Barthel Index and care giver practices (P= 0.773)
Socio demographic variables |
Dependent |
Assisted |
Independent |
X |
P-value |
||||
No |
% |
No |
% |
No |
% |
||||
Age |
|
||||||||
40 : 45 |
1 |
0.5 |
8 |
4.4 |
22 |
12.2 |
49.12 |
.128 NS |
|
45 : 50 |
6 |
3.3 |
22 |
12.2 |
20 |
11.1 |
|||
50 : 55 |
1 |
0.5 |
30 |
16.6 |
18 |
10 |
|||
55 : 60 |
7 |
3.8 |
18 |
10 |
24 |
13.3 |
|||
Family member |
|
||||||||
2-3 |
3 |
1.6 |
12 |
6.6 |
17 |
9.4 |
27.14 |
.402 NS |
|
4-5 |
11 |
6.1 |
60 |
33.3 |
48 |
26.6 |
|||
> 5 |
1 |
0.5 |
9 |
5 |
19 |
10.5 |
|||
Medical diagnosis |
|
||||||||
Stroke |
8 |
4.4 |
43 |
23.8 |
36 |
20 |
94.89 |
.000* |
|
Tumor |
6 |
3.3 |
7 |
2.8 |
2 |
1.1 |
|||
Bleeding |
1 |
0.5 |
9 |
5 |
5 |
2.7 |
|||
Hypertension Complication |
0 |
0 |
22 |
12.2 |
41 |
22.7 |
|||
NS = not significance P – value ≤ 0.05 *=significant
Table (5) illustrates that, there are statistical significance differences between total BARTHEL INDEX practices among adult at home with medical diagnosis (p-value = 0.00)
Socio demographic variables |
Unsatisfied |
Satisfied |
X |
P-value |
||
No |
% |
No |
% |
|||
Social status |
||||||
Single |
5 |
2.7 |
0 |
0 |
87.3a |
.928 NS |
Married |
128 |
71 |
15 |
8.3 |
||
Divorced |
23 |
12.7 |
0 |
0 |
||
Windowed |
8 |
4.4 |
1 |
0.5 |
||
Intensive care unit (ICU) admission |
||||||
Yes |
59 |
32.7 |
0 |
0 |
54.0a |
.027 * |
No |
105 |
58.3 |
16 |
8.8 |
||
Educational level |
||||||
Illiterate |
85 |
47.2 |
10 |
5.5 |
91.6 |
.945 NS |
Reading |
68 |
37.7 |
5 |
2.7 |
||
University |
11 |
6.1 |
1 |
0.5 |
NS = not significance *P – value ≤ 0.05 *=significant
Table (6): shows that, there are statistical significance differences between total practice patient care givers at home with ICU patient admission. It is observed that 58.3% of care givers having unsatisfactory practice level of care, (p-value = 0.027)
Figure (1): explores that, 43.3% of post stroke patient are independent for feeding and 20% of them are unable, also 46.7 % of study clients need help during toilet and 26.7% unable, and 45.7% of them need help during bathing and shower time. As regard as 42.2 % of post stroke patient need help during dressing clothes but only 14.4 % of them is unable. On the other hand there are 14.4. % of study patients is dependent, and 44.4% of them are independent to mobile while 39.4
% needs help during climbing stairs also 28.3% are unable to move up stairs
Figure (2) summarizes that 75% of the study sample become depressed as quickly as 68 % of them has infected by pneumonia .with inside the equal case 65% of submit stroke sufferers from urinary tract infection. How approximately that 72% of them have mattress sores and seizures post stroke, on the other hand 74% of study sample complain of deep venous thrombosis while 63 % of them have a limb contractions
Figure (3) clears that 46.7% of my study sample are independent for total Barthel Index while 8.3% are dependent to others during doing their activities
Figure (4) shows that 66.1 % of my study sample are satisfied for total post stroke care while 33.9 % of them are unsatisfied to others during doing their activities.
The present study result showed that, more than half of study sample were old age, the most of observed sample were married while two third of studied sample were have insufficient income to their family, the present results agree with Wagachchige et al., (2018), who reported that more than half of study sample were old age most of them were have not enough money .The current study revealed that less than two third of stroke patients were males. The current result is consistent with Fekadu et al., (2019) who found that most of stroke patient were male. This reflects that males are more commonly devoted for managing home and works and for caring family members.
The present study results reflected that more than three quarters of the stroke patients were married. The present study similar findings as Anderson et al., (2017) who reported that less than three quarters of post stroke patient were married, Also, Ayasrah et al., (2018), reported that the most of post stroke patient were married.
The current study results clarified that, more than half of stroke patients caregivers of the studied sample were living with their stroke patients adult and available at any time. This result agrees with xing et al., (2020), who said that more than half of the studied samples were living with their stroke patients and available at any time.
The present study results supplied that much less than half of my observed sample has been complained from high blood pressure as regard to onset of analysis the of prevalence the stroke so much less than one third of the study stroke patients admitted to ICU unit. This end result concurs with Mwenda et al., (2019) who pronounced that, hypertension and diabetes mellitus are stroke risk factors and correlated in patients.
The present study results explored that, less than half of study sample were independent for feeding, this result agrees with Wilmskoetter et al., (2019) who reported that forty four stroke patients at hospital discharge, the most of patients had oral intake restrictions and one quarter were feeding tube dependent. From the investigator point of view this result study is due to most caregivers intended to show their care to client and because of the severity of disease attacked client.
The present study results showed that more than half of post-stroke caregivers were giving patient medications on time, this referred that most of informal caregivers provide medication early after discharge. The investigator thinks this result may be accumulation of following doctor order and fear of deterioration.
The present study results showed that less than half of caregivers used medications in right way of administration, this result agreed with Moon et al., (2016) who reported that less than half of study cases take them correctly and understanding the right way to administer them can reduce the risks. Also the present study result discovered that less than half of president study sample did not store medications correctly. This result agrees with Parand et al.,(2018), who reported that potential drug administration errors take a look at end result determined that more than half of my take a look at pattern did now no longer keep medicinal drugs correctly. This may be due to lack of the health education about medication on discharge.
The present study results summarized that the most of study sample was suffering from depression this come in agree with Loh et al., ( 2017) who reported that the high prevalence of depressive and anxiety symptoms among caregivers of stroke survivors. In my opinion, high rate of depression for post stroke patient may be related to long term complete bed ridden, social isolation and financial effort.
Regarding practices of caregivers the present study showed that two third have urinary tract infection this come in agree with Elnady et al., (2018) whoreported that "urinary tract infection was found in less than three quarters of their subjects.
Regarding practices of caregivers the existing examine confirmed that there's no sizable correlation among Barthel Index and caregiver practices. This come in agree with de Weerd et al., (2016) who said there has been no sizable distinction among the median Barthel Index fee at discharge from health center. The present study results identified that less than half of study sample were independent for total Barthel Index. These results agreed with xing et al., (2020) who revealed that more than half of stroke patients were totally independent in their patterns of daily activities.
The present study results cleared that half of study sample were independent for total Barthel Index this come in agree with Huenges et al., (2017) who said that almost two-thirds of patients were independent for the activities of daily livings (ADL) experienced problems of participation six months after stroke .
The present study results showed that two third of studied sample were satisfied for total post stroke care, this come in agree with Fujimaki et al., (2021) who said that "the vast majority of people who have had a stroke and their spouses were satisfied for total post stroke care -term satisfaction with aspects of "closeness" decline. In the investigator opinion , This may be due to the patients with stroke have distinct characteristics, they were not able to care for themselves, and some of them were not able to express their needs which leads caregivers to spend a lot of time with them and increase the amount of care giving by caregivers.
The present study results illustrated that there were statistical significance differences between total Barthel Index practices among adult at home with medical diagnosis .These results can be explained as the sit and the severity of the stroke detect the ability of the patient to practice the activity of daily living. There were statistical significance differences between total practice patient care givers at home with ICU patient admission, it was observed that two third of caregivers having unsatisfactory practice level of care, this contraindicated with Saab et al.,(2019), who said several easily measured variables were significantly associated with discharge to long term care versus home following stroke rehabilitation
From the investigator's point of view, which we need to bear in mind on this research, as a huge percentage of post-thrombotic patients suffer from signs and symptoms of complications, this suggests a loss of interest to them from the factor of view of caregivers or companions, and the proof is that the occurrence of urinary tract infections and the incidence of depression, as maximum The instances had depression, and it became discovered that post-stroke sufferers, at some stage in our follow-as much as the instances, the disease ends in the incidence of bed sores from the social lifestyle of the sufferers' hygiene since the Egyptian lifestyle is involved with the cleanliness of the affected person first, even supposing it comes on the cost of treatment, wherein humans are in economic ways. We stay in a materialistic society, apart from a few social groups, that are involved with their presence in non-public hospitals
Based on the findings of the present study, it can be concluded that less than the half of post stroke patients were complained from hypertension, while less than half of post stroke patient were independent for feeding, Also more than half of post-stroke caregivers gave patient medications on time and less than half of them used medications in right way of administration, and half did not store medications correctly.
The most of stroke patients was suffering from depression and two third have urinary tract infection. As regarding relationships the half of study sample were independent for total Barthel Index in spite of there were two third of studied sample were satisfied for total post stroke care . There were statistical significance differences between total Barthel Index practices among adult at home with medical diagnosis but there wasn’t significant correlation between Barthel Index and caregiver practices. Finally, there were statistical significance differences between total practice patient care givers at home with ICU patient admission
- Application and implementation of domestic fitness schooling through manner of approach of all stroke units, outpatient neurology clinics, and physiotherapy clinics.
- More researches are desired to investigate the various factors that boom caregiver burden and pain on the way to find out the proper solution.
- Spread of educational leaflets, posters, pamphlets, and booklets on recurrent cerebrovascular attacks and related way of life modifications ought to be established.
- Develop a crew of discharge plan in governmental and private hospitals to be accountable approximately imparting the sufferers and their own circle of relatives caregivers with the wished know-how and practice, which could be carried out at domestic.
- Provide the network with the preventive records measures about the stroke disease